Advertisment

McCarthy's Debt Ceiling Deal Praised, But Faces Criticism from Conservative Republicans

author-image
Dil Bar Irshad
New Update
House Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) sits for debt limit talks with U.S. President Joe Biden in the Oval Office at the White House in Washington, U.S., May 22, 2023.
<br>
Image Credit: REUTERS/Leah Millis

Concerns Over Credibility Issues and Promised Spending Cuts

Advertisment

U.S. House of Representatives Speaker Kevin McCarthy received praise for the debt ceiling deal he negotiated with President Joe Biden. However, prominent House conservative Representative Ken Buck expressed concerns about McCarthy's credibility and the lack of promised spending cuts. Buck, a member of the far-right House Freedom Caucus, stated that the deal did not deliver the deeper spending reductions that McCarthy had pledged when running for speaker earlier this year.

The debt ceiling deal maintains fiscal 2024 spending at current levels, with a 1% increase for fiscal 2025. While the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office estimates that the deal will reduce deficits by approximately $1.5 trillion over a decade, it fell short of the House Republicans late April demand for $4.8 trillion deficit reduction over the same period.

Questions Surrounding McCarthy's Leadership and Future Challenges

Advertisment

Concerns over McCarthy's leadership and potential challenges emerged within the Freedom Caucus. Buck indicated that McCarthy's credibility issues could prompt some Republicans to seek his ouster as the top Republican in Congress. Although Buck mentioned the possibility of a motion to vacate, he did not confirm its immediate occurrence. McCarthy's vulnerability to hardline conservative Republicans stems from rule changes he agreed to during the January election process for the speakership, allowing a single member to force a vote for his removal.

While some Republicans defended McCarthy, emphasizing the importance of his position, others raised doubts about the debt ceiling deal and its implications. Representative Garret Graves, a Louisiana Republican involved in the negotiation of the deal, assured that McCarthy's position is secure. However, concerns persist among those who expected greater spending cuts.

McCarthy defended the deal, highlighting its reduction in non-defense discretionary spending and its prevention of additional Internal Revenue Service hires. He also emphasized increased funding for defense and veterans, acknowledging that although the deal is not perfect, it marks the beginning of addressing spending issues and requires further action.

The deal garnered support from 149 House Republicans, alongside 165 Democrats, but faced opposition from 46 Democrats who criticized its stringent work requirements for recipients of food assistance and monetary aid. Senator Mike Lee, a conservative Republican from Utah, also expressed disapproval, stating that the deal could lead to a $4 trillion increase in U.S. debt by the start of 2025.

The future trajectory of McCarthy's leadership will depend on his actions during upcoming spending negotiations and his reliance on Democratic votes to pass legislation, as observed in the debt ceiling agreement. The criticism surrounding the deal raises questions about the effectiveness of future bipartisan cooperation and the potential challenges McCarthy may face from within his own party.

Advertisment
Advertisment