Declining Vaccination Rates Among Children in Scotland’s NHS Highland Region: A Deep Dive
Falling Vaccination Rates: A Cause for Concern
Scotland’s National Health Service (NHS) Highland region has witnessed a concerning decrease in the vaccination rates among children, as revealed by a leaked internal report. The uptake of the four-in-one vaccine, which provides protection against diphtheria, whooping cough, tetanus, and polio, has declined to its lowest level in almost a decade. As of June, only 86.5% of five-year-olds had received the pre-school booster, a significant fall from the 91.6% recorded in June 2022.
The report also indicates that the percentage of five-year-olds receiving their first MMR dose fell year-on-year, from 97.1% to 94.5%. Similarly, the Hib/MenC booster against meningitis C and Haemophilus influenzae Type B (Hib) saw a drop from 97.2% to 93.7%. Coverage for some infant vaccinations, including rotavirus, the pneumococcal vaccine (PCV), and combined inoculations against tetanus, whooping cough, polio, Hep B, and Hib also declined. On the other hand, the first dose of MMR among two-year-olds saw a slight increase, from 89.8% to 91.5%.
Vaccine Delivery Shift: A Controversial Move
The drop in vaccination rates coincides with the contentious transfer of responsibility for vaccine delivery from GP surgeries to the health board, a change that commenced in March. This move was designed to alleviate the workload of GPs as per the 2018 Scottish GP contract. However, doctors in the Highlands have contended that the region’s remote and rural geography makes it more feasible for GP practices to continue administering vaccinations in-house. The leaked report indicates that the health board is struggling to implement the Vaccine Transformation Programme (VTP) model, given the region’s geography and demography.
Challenges in Vaccination Delivery
The report highlights several issues, including long journeys to clinics, staffing shortages at health board-run vaccination hubs resulting in cancellations, and extended waiting periods for appointments. Between March and May, 64 childhood vaccination clinics were cancelled across Lochaber, Skye, and Highland, impacting 114 pre-booked patient appointments. The report also criticises the lack of an “options appraisal” to enable willing GP practices to continue administering vaccines in their area, a strategy implemented in the Argyll and Bute Health and Social Care Partnership area.
Response from NHS Highland
In response to the issues highlighted in the report, NHS Highland acknowledged the need for improvements in the design of its vaccination service. The health service expressed a commitment to delivering vaccinations as close to local communities as possible, indicating a willingness to adapt its approach in light of the challenges faced.
The decline in vaccination rates among children in Scotland’s NHS Highland region is a worrying trend with potential public health implications. While the shift in vaccine delivery responsibility was intended to ease the burden on GPs, it has been met with practical challenges and controversy. As the health board acknowledges the need for service design improvements, the hope is that these issues will be addressed effectively, leading to a reversal of the declining vaccination rates.
Subscribe to BNN Breaking
Sign up for our daily newsletter covering global breaking news around the world.